5 Best Natural Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes in 2020

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
woman applying mascara

My desert-island product: mascara

There’s just something about swiping a few coats onto my eyelashes that makes me feel ready to take on the day, even when the rest of my face is bare.

Even though my love affair with mascara is ever-lasting, my eyes are incredibly sensitive to some of the harsher ingredients that can be included, which made it a constant challenge to find the perfect product.

In recent years, I was seldom impressed with the results I’d get from clean beauty mascara. It could never stand up to its mainstream counterparts- I wouldn’t achieve the length and volume I’d always crave.

But in recent years, clean beauty has taken huge strides towards revolutionizing our perception of what it means to be “clean.” Taking notes from industry leaders and listening to their consumers, these companies now craft high-performing products, particularly natural mascaras for sensitive eyes, that stand up to competitors and win the hearts of many, myself included. Since then, I’ve fully made the switch to clean, natural mascara and never looked back. 

Here are the top 5 best natural mascaras for sensitive eyes: 

Honest Beauty 

Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer   

Honest Beauty’s mascara gives you fuller, longer-looking lashes. What I love about this product is that it’s dual-ended. On one side, the built-in primer preps your lashes to receive maximum length and volume, while the mascara ties it together to give bold definition.

As part of their promise, Honest delivers when it comes to clean, safe ingredients, eliminating the use of parabens, paraffin, synthetic fragrances, silicones, and mineral oil. A key ingredient – jojoba esters– are a safe emollient that helps to condition lash hairs. With countless rave reviews that speak to the quality and effectiveness of Honest’s mascara, you really can’t go wrong with this purchase. 

Price: $16.99 

Where to purchase: Amazon, Honest Beauty, Ulta 

honest beauty mascara - best natural mascaras for sensitive eyes


Limitless Lash Mascara 

If you love a minimalist look, Ilia’s Limitless Lash Mascara is your go-to. This product gives you sky-high length and feels virtually weightless on the lashes.

Made with 99% natural ingredients, including shea butter and arginine, it’s gentle for the most sensitive eyes. While it doesn’t give you dramatic volume, this mascara’s unique formula enhances your lashes – in the most natural way possible. Think your lashes but better. I love this mascara on days when I want to achieve the no-makeup makeup look

Price: $28 

Where to purchase: The Detox Market, Ilia, Sephora

ilia limitless lash mascara

Kjaer Weiss 

Lush-up Volumizing Mascara 

Have you ever added multiple coats of mascara and quickly realized you made an epic mistake? Clumps form, lashes glue together, and it looks downright messy. I’ve had my fair share of mascara mess-ups, but never with Kjaer Weiss’s Lush-Up Volumizing Mascara.

Rosehip seed oil and rosemary extract aid in boosting the product’s efficacy while promoting a no-fail approach to additional layers. In fact, I believe this mascara only gets better when you add more than a single coat. I notice increased boldness, length, and the curl stays put throughout the day. 

Price: $38, refills are $28.

Where to purchase: Credo Beauty, Revolve, Kjaer Weiss 

kjaer weiss lush up volumizing mascara

Lily Lolo 

Big Lash Mascara 

Lily Lolo’s Big Lash Mascara promises to deliver instant, voluminous results. Its formula is vegan and free of any harmful ingredients, like parabens and lead. The wand has an hourglass shape (similar to the Too Faced Better than Sex mascara) to give you those bold, fluttery lashes.

Also, the bristles look to coat even those pesky hard-to-reach hairs- seriously, I’m a huge fan of this wand. What makes this a standout product is how it successfully manages to lift your lashes to its fullest length while preventing any fallout.

Price: $22

Where to purchase: The Detox Market, Lily Lolo 

lily lolo mascara

Beauty counter 

Volumizing Mascara 

EWG Verified, Beauty Counter’s Volumizing Mascara gets the seal of approval for meeting the highest health and safety standards. Plant-derived ingredients carnauba wax and bataua oil are incorporated into the formula to soften the lashes and replace their harmful counterparts. 

This mascara produces dramatic looking lashes, free of clumping, smudging, and flaking. Adding 2-3 coats is the sweet spot to achieving a denser-looking lash line, mimicking the effects of a liner. It’s beauty trickery at its best. 

Price: $36

Where to purchase: Beauty Counter

beauty counter mascara

Final Thoughts 

These mascaras are the best of the best in the clean beauty world. They’ll give you the results you want, minus the harmful ingredients. Not to mention that burning sensation you receive when you wash off your eye makeup. Sound familiar?

Selecting a top favorite is no easy feat, considering they all are worthy of a purchase. However, the one I always gravitate towards is the Honest Beauty’s Extreme Length and Lash Primer. It gives me all the drama and length that I’m after. And it makes my eyes really pop, come alive – in one single coat.

*Prices may vary